These were care Proceedings where David Sharp represented the children. The LA plan was to move the children to their father’s care under a child arrangements order. The legal test the Court should apply was disputed. The Mother argued that, as these were public law proceedings, the public law test for a removal under an ICO should apply, in other words that the children’s immediate physical, psychological or emotional safety required their removal from the Mother’s care. It was argued by David on behalf of the children that the private law test for an interim switch of “lives with” arrangements applied as this was a private law order moving children from one parent to another. This was a less sharp interference with family life than placing children in foster care and was more likely to be a proportionate response to the concerns. This required simply application of the welfare test and “compelling reasons” for such a switch at an interim stage. The Court adopted the latter private law test and made the child arrangements order for the children to live with the Father at this interim stage.