Joan Connell represented the mother in a case which evolved from private law proceedings into care proceedings following a long running dispute between the parents over who should care for and spend time with the children. Allegations of coercive and controlling behaviour were made by the mother against the father with regard to his behaviour towards her and the children but were not found proven. There were difficulties with expert evidence and the Court determined that the psychological report was not reliable and should be disregarded. The Court criticised professionals for adopting allegations as if proven facts. The mother accepted that she was not in a position to care for the children. The Court placed the children with their father contrary to the recommendations of the local authority and two Children’s Guardian’s. In doing so the Court determined that it was making “the least worst option, neither [of which] is ideal”.