High Court case where subject girl, a Hong Kong citizen, was taken into care after the Mother was filmed in England severely beating her. The Father and the Paternal Aunt wanted to care for her in HK. The child did not want to go back to HK as she feared that neither the Father nor the Aunt, otherwise able carers, would protect her from the Mother. Both Father and Aunt had to come here to give sworn evidence as it was decided remote sworn evidence from HK needed permission from the Chinese government. While wardship to the HK High Court might give some protection, it was held the child was being reasonable to fear for her safety and in those circumstances it would be too emotionally harmful to send her back to HK.